Choose the simplest automation form
A script, skill, MCP server, and plugin solve different problems. Start with the simplest solution that removes a real recurring need; do not add packaging complexity for its own sake.
Components can combine: a script gathers facts, a skill defines an analysis workflow, MCP adds current external data, and a plugin distributes a verified set.
| Form | When to choose it | Scale |
|---|---|---|
| Manual action | One-off or not yet proven repeatable | Personal work |
| Script | Repeatable local mechanics | Developer or repository |
| Skill | Team needs a consistent Claude workflow and output format | Project or team |
| MCP | Live external data or operations are necessary | Controlled integration |
| Plugin | A verified package must be delivered to multiple places | Teams and repositories |
Do not confuse component responsibilities
- A script provides simple predictable mechanics.
- A skill describes inputs, analysis sequence, and response format.
- MCP provides a controlled bridge to external data or actions.
- A plugin packages a verified workflow for delivery, versioning, and consistent installation.
- No packaging form gains authority to make business decisions.
Selection logic
- If an action happened once, do it manually.
- If one person repeats a local command, create a script.
- If several people use the same analysis procedure, create a skill.
- If the result is incomplete without live external data, consider MCP.
- If a verified workflow is needed in several repositories, evaluate a plugin.
manual action
-> local script
-> team skill
-> MCP for external data
-> plugin for distributionRoll out gradually with boundaries
A local helper should not silently become a mandatory gate. An external integration should not receive more access than its scenario requires.
| Component | Minimum check |
|---|---|
| Script | Repeatable local result and clear disable method |
| Skill | Stable input, output contract, and usage example |
| MCP | Read-only scenario, narrow data scope, and verified auth path |
| Plugin | Provenance, versioning, compatibility, docs, and rollback |
Ready for team use
- README includes start instructions, an example, and expected result.
- An owner and supported scope are defined.
- Someone other than the author has tested the tool.
- The interface and versions are stable.
- Logs, disable switch, and rollback path are documented.
- The team knows how to react to an incorrect result.
Canonical lesson source · JavaRush
Open JavaRush material